The leadership sweet spot: empathy and accountability

Balancing the heart (empathy) and the brain (logic) is a powerful metaphor for leadership. Great leaders cultivate both emotional connection and a backbone for tough decisions.

Running a business isn’t just a job – it’s a craft you can continually master. After 30 years of coaching and consulting with leaders around the world, I’ve learned one big truth: the real secret to sustainable business growth is balancing empathy with accountability. In plain terms, that means staying human and making the tough calls.

This balance isn’t a touchy-feely concept; it’s a practical leadership strategy. As your company grows, your success depends less on what you do personally and more on what your team delivers. You might have started as the star performer, but as you scale up (especially in a C-level role) your impact comes through others. And that’s why learning to lead with both heart and spine is so crucial.

Empathy vs. Accountability – Finding the Sweet Spot

In my business coaching sessions, I regularly see two types of leaders at opposite sides. Some leaders default to being tough as nails. They set high standards, make quick decisions, and expect results. This decisive approach can drive performance – at least while the numbers are good – but it often alienates people. These leaders sometimes succeed despite themselves, until cracks appear in the team’s morale. Other leaders default to being endlessly kind and accommodating. They’re great listeners and supportive bosses. But because they avoid conflict and hard conversations, they eventually lose effectiveness; their team drifts or underperforms due to lack of clear direction.

There’s no “good” or “bad” style here per se – there are many ways to be successful. But either extreme becomes a liability over time. A one-trick pony leader, stuck with just one approach, has limited long-term success. The truth is, every business leader needs both of these muscles: empathy and accountability. One usually feels more natural to you; the other might need deliberate work – like strengthening a weaker muscle at the gym. The encouraging news is that with practice, you can develop the side that doesn’t come naturally. It starts with knowing yourself. Ask yourself honestly: Which way do I lean? Do you tend to be too hard on your people, or too easy on them? Self-awareness is the first step to finding your sweet spot on the spectrum. Great leaders are adaptable – they vary their approach based on the circumstances and the people involved.

How the Best Leaders Blend Heart and Spine

Let me share what my most successful clients do differently. They genuinely care about their people – and their people know it. These leaders stay emotionally close to the team: they listen, show respect, and build trust. They understand that success is a two-way street. When your team members feel valued, they want to go the extra mile for you. However, truly great leaders also hold their people accountable. They’re not afraid to set bold targets, give frank feedback, or make hard decisions. In short, they have a certain sharpness or backbone. They might not always be “easy” or pleasing to everyone, and that’s okay. Because they’ve invested heavily in trust – think of it like making deposits in an emotional bank account over time – their people still respect and stick with them when tough decisions or changes come down.

Balancing warmth with toughness is a skill that very few are born with. For the rest of us, it takes conscious practice. Is this rocket science? No. Is it easy to change your habits and comfort zone? Definitely not! But it is absolutely doable. I’ve seen leaders transform their impact by gradually stretching into their less-developed side. The key is consistency and willingness to learn. And remember, being a compassionate leader doesn’t mean you’re a pushover, and being a results-driven leader doesn’t mean you’re a drill sergeant – the best blend of both.

What Can You Do Tomorrow?

By now you might be thinking, “Alright, I get it – but how do I start balancing empathy and accountability in real life?” The answer: start with small, deliberate actions and start immediately. Here are a few practical steps you can take as soon as tomorrow:

• Look in the mirror (self-assess): Take 10 minutes to reflect on your default leadership style. Are you more of a driver or a nurturer? Jot down one strength and one weakness in how you lead your team. This honest check-in is crucial – you can’t improve what you don’t acknowledge.

• Seek candid feedback: Reach out to a couple of trusted colleagues or team members and ask for their honest perspective. For example, you might say, “I’m working on becoming a better leader. In tough situations, do I come across as too harsh, or do I sometimes avoid issues?” Be open to what they tell you. It might sting or it might affirm what you suspected, but either way you’ll gain valuable insight.

• Choose one new action and do it: Pick a specific way to stretch your less-developed side tomorrow. If you tend to be the “nice” leader who avoids hard conversations, identify one issue you need to address – maybe a piece of tough feedback for a team member – and plan to deliver it kindly but clearly. If you’re more of the hard-driving type, find an opportunity to show extra empathy – for instance, spend time listening to a team member’s concerns or give praise and recognition where you normally wouldn’t. The key is to step a bit outside your comfort zone and demonstrate that other side of your leadership.

Making these changes feels personal because it is personal – it’s about you growing as a leader. Don’t be discouraged if it feels awkward at first. Remember, you’re practicing a new skill. Just like working out, progress comes with repetition and gradual increases in challenge.

Finally, keep in mind this guiding principle: be hard on the matter, but soft on the people. In practice, that means set high standards and hold your team to them (don’t compromise on the results you need), while treating your people with respect and understanding. If you can manage that duality, you’ll create a culture of trust and high performance.

The bottom line: Your future success as a leader – and the success of your business – depends on mastering both heart and spine. The best leaders lead with both compassion and conviction. So start flexing those underused leadership muscles. Your team will thank you, and your business’s growth will reflect the difference. I’m rooting for you – now go out there tomorrow and lead with the courage to care and to hold accountable!

Hope this inspires


Paul Donkers

About Paul
For decades, Paul has been the trusted business coach and advisor to leaders around the world. His work is built on deep, hands-on experience—not abstract models. Paul and his partners have guided countless leaders and teams through growth phases, complex strategic decisions, and leadership breakthroughs. Their focus: helping organizations build more value today while shaping the leadership needed for the future.

If you’re ready to explore how expert guidance could support your next chapter, visit www.tencompany.org or www.ikigaicoachinginstitute.com.
For a confidential conversation, contact This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it.